Well, readers, you made a fine choice when you selected Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookies for a new recipe in Webkinz World during our Winterfest Cookie Poll!
I just baked up a batch for myself and let me tell you – they are delicious.
Here’s the recipe…
…Nah! You didn’t think it was going to be THAT easy, did you? The fun is in figuring out the recipe for yourself. And remember, the first person to discover the correct recipe wins a Secret Chef Trophy!
So get baking and crack that cookie recipe!
Awesome but ugh!!! How will we crack the code? Where is Chef Gazpacho when you need him? Currently spending all my Kinzcash trying to figure this out! XD
I tried a few different ideas….all I got was gak. LOL
Wow! This sounds like a great cookie- and challenge!
same here im the gunk master! i have a feeling the recipe has toffee in it. read the description of the toffee, its the only one OUT OF ALL OF THEM that says ‘Lovely’. and then maybe lemon meringue pie, or umm cookies XD
Figuring out recipes is so difficult, but I’d sure love to get these cookies!
Mmm – Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookies look delicious! Definitely baking in WW today – Thanks for the heads up on this awesome new recipe, Sophie! Good luck, everyone :)
Aaahhhhhahaha so realistic and delicious-looking… (゜﹃゜ )
Nom yom.. yes it does. ;]
Yummy! :)
Thats me i best at cooking
Ohh, cool! So it’s a mystery recipe, hmmm… Yeah, I dunno. xP I’ll leave this stuff to the expert Kinz Chefs.
Haha, yeah, I have no idea what it is. :/ maybe I’ll try to figure it out when I go on webkinz later.
Cool! Aw man, I won’t be able to go on Webkinz till later :/ Well, it’s okay. Good luck everyone on trying to find the recipe! :)
Thanks, Taffy! I think I’ll try sometime today. I can’t wait until it’s recipe is discovered! These cookies sound good. :P
You’re welcome :) And yeah, I can’t wait, either! :D I voted for the double chocolate chocolate chip cookies (those are my favorite type of cookies in real life) but hey, these lemon cookies look really good, too!!! :D
I guess we try everything!
I voted for the Peanut Butter Cookies, because they looked good and the recipe is super easy. I made them a few months ago and they turned out great! They’re really yummy. :P
Oh wow, those sound good, RosyFox :) I’ve never had a peanut butter cookie before. I bet they taste great ^•^ I voted for the double chocolate chocolate chip cookies because, well, I love chocolate chip cookies… And I especially like it when they are chocolate all the way ;D To be honest, I actually thought the double chocolate chocolate chip cookies would win, and I was a little disappointed when they didn’t, I don’t know, I guess I didn’t think a lemon cookie would be such a popular choice, but hey, the lemon ones look pretty good if I do say so myself :) I can’t wait till the recipe is revealed! Well, at least, hopefully, person who discovers it will tell us. I sure hope so, hehe, cause I’d love to make these cookies sometime soon :)
Ooh, peanut butter cookies and double chocolate chip cookies sound sooo good!! I don’t I think ended up voting, I guess I forgot. :| I probably wouldn’t have been able to choose anyways though, because lemon cookies sound good too, and I bet all the other ones did as well. :) and TaffyKitty, I can’t wait till the recipe is revealed either!! these cookies look so good! plus, its probably the most realistic recipe they have on webkinz. ;)
I love double chocolate chip cookies, too, Taffy! I kind of a choco-holic, I can’t resist chocolaty desserts! There are so many types of cookies that I like…I can’t list them all off right now! ^u^
I meant “I’m” instead of “I”. Lol, I just sounded like cookie monster! xD
It’s okay, ilovemoonie! I think I only voted once or twice during the voting period, hehe… I guess I kind of forgot about it after a while. And hehe, yeah, I bet it would’ve been tough to decide! I was debating whether to choose double chocolate chocolate chip or regular chocolate chip, but I settled on the first one. Mainly since I like them a bit better than normal chocolate chip cookies, plus they sounded more… I don’t know… Unique I guess considering the cookies avaliable in the w shop look an awful lot like normal chocolate chip cookies. I still kinda wish my pick ended up winning, but when I think about it, who doesn’t want their pick to end up winning? Hehe…. But hey, these lemon cookies look pretty cool!! Can’t wait to find out the recipe :)
Hehe, same here RosyFox! I love chocolate desserts! Chocolate chip cookies… Chocolate milkshakes, chocolate ice cream, extra chocolatey brownies, chocolate cake… And ooh… One of my favorites…. Chocolate lava cake! I love em all! Yeah….. I guess you can call me a “chocolate lover” XD And it’s okay! I make typos all the time!
Let’s do this thing! LOL! Yeah right, I’ll leave the hard stuff to the experimenting experts :P
II voted for this so I’m very happy that it won! Ugh…. How will we figure this out? But remember, “We’re all in this together….” *Everyone joins in!!!* XD
I only meant to say “I” not “II”! Sorry!
Yeah, me too! I made some about a month ago. Boy, were they good! =D I’m not exactly what you would call a recipe guessing expert, but it’s worth a shot!
They look great. Good luck everyone.