NEW Recipe Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie!

Well, readers, you made a fine choice when you selected Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookies for a new recipe in Webkinz World during our Winterfest Cookie Poll!

 

I just baked up a batch for myself and let me tell you – they are delicious.

 

Here’s the recipe…

 

…Nah! You didn’t think it was going to be THAT easy, did you? The fun is in figuring out the recipe for yourself. And remember, the first person to discover the correct recipe wins a Secret Chef Trophy!

So get baking and crack that cookie recipe!

64 Responses to NEW Recipe Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie!

  1. hillry says:

    Lovely lemon cookie recipe has been solved. To mahe use the stove with pink lemonade and fudge and waffles. Make some!!!!

  2. Elizabeh says:

    For the Lovely Lemon Cookies, I have so far tried: Toffee/WK Crackers with each of the following, and gotten fails: ice cream, pink lemonade, lemon meringue pie, eggs, cookies. I have tried Toffee/Ice cream for each of the following, and gotten fails: pink lemonade, lemon pie, cookies, eggs, potato chips. I have further tried Lemon pie/eggs/ice cream, which is a fail. I have tried Toffee/asparagus with each of the following, and got fails: cookies, ice cream, WK crackers, lemon pie, pink lemonade, potato chips, baked potato. I’m posting this here, since the cookie recipe link isn’t posted yet.

  3. Raven578 says:

    Sally does it have lemon meringue pie in it?

  4. HeavenFire25 says:

    does it have lemon meringue pie?

  5. HeavenFire25 says:

    do you think lemon meringue pie is in it?

  6. Cherrycheesecake says:

    Which kind of item do you use? Stove?

  7. loveyou1996 says:

    lemonade goes in it

Leave a Reply