Polly’s Cake

Hey, it’s Molly and the plans for Polly’s surprise party are going really well! I don’t think she suspects a thing! The only problem is that we couldn’t decide what kind of cake to make. We all want something different. Alex said that girls like flowers so we should have a cake with flowers on it. Way to stereotype, Alex! Stoogles says that he is a traditionalist and that a plain old birthday cake with her name on it is all we need. You know how crafty Roberta can be? Well, she wants to design a cake with Polly’s face on it. Sounds complicated. And Nibbles and I both love cupcakes. Aren’t cupcakes always better than cake?

So we thought the best thing to do would be to go off in pairs and come up with a cake design. Then we could choose our favorite design and make that one. Maybe you could help us choose.

 

Alex & Sparky

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Girls like flowers, right? That’s why Sparky and I wanted to make this neat chocolate cake for Polly. She’s a girl. We even made purple icing by mixing red and blue food coloring. Cool, huh?

 

Stoogles & Salley

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Salley and I decided to do a very simple white cake with pink and blue icing. I think that Polly will really appreciate a good, old fashioned birthday cake.

 

Roberta & Cowabelle

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I wanted to make a cake that really represented Polly. So Cowabelle and I made this really simple design of a panda cake using black and white icing.

 

Molly & Nibbles

 

 

 

 

 

 

Nibbles and I love cupcakes so we decided to make panda paw print cupcakes! Aren’t they cute? We used different colors of icing for the base and then put a paw print on each one!

 

So what do you think? Which cake should we make for the party?

98 Responses to Polly’s Cake

  1. DandieDinmonts says:

    Cupcakes are a popular thing right now. I say go with the cupcakes. Easy to eat, fun to make! You could even use everyone different ideas in coordinating colors!

  2. powerpuffgirlfan says:

    I love Roberta and Cowabelle cake!
    It looks cool and I love it! ~powerpuffgirlsfan~

  3. HamsterHuey says:

    Molly and Nibbles’s cupcakes are adorable! I vote for those!

  4. wylady says:

    I love Sparky and Alex’s cake, but personally I think that Polly will love the idea of giving each guest their own cupcake…and how sweet with her “paw print” signature on each guest personal little cake!

  5. hedgymama says:

    I like Alex and Sparky’s the best, but Molly and Nibbles’ cupcakes are super cute too :)

  6. geva4isawesome says:

    I can’t decide!!! They all look great!!! MDIChickadee that is an awesome idea for the cupcakes!!!

  7. horsecowgirlup says:

    I have had cupcakes before for cake and I kinda missed having a real cake. So I’m going with Roberta’s and Cowbelle’s.

  8. Drafthorse says:

    I totally agree with you! I think Sallys and Stoogles cake is the most wonderful you need to have a nice plain cake to show your love for your friend or maybe even family member.

  9. lovepuppygirl says:

    I VOTE FOR ROBERTA AND COWBELLE`S!!!!!!!!!!

  10. Jellydonut says:

    Oh Stooges cake is just darling!(I call Stoogles Stooges)

Leave a Reply