Jest the Best Bagel: Secret Sandwich Recipe Revealed!


Not all the recipes in Webkinz Classic are quite so secret, but they are all definitely fun to discover! The Jest the Best Bagel is one such recipe for sandwich makers—you only need to find two other ingredients to add to your bagel to create the fun face of a jolly jester!


Just pick up the following 3 ingredients from the WShop and then combine them in any sandwich maker in Webkinz Classic to create the best bagel that will put a smile on your face AND your food!




Want to know about MORE Webkinz Secret Recipes? Check out our Secret Recipe archive here!


Have you discovered the stove recipes in Webkinz Next yet? They’re fun and easy to make!
Just click on a stove once you’ve added it to your room and it will show you a list of recipe foods. You can select any of these recipe foods to learn which ingredients are required.



Unlike Classic, some recipes may require multiples of a single ingredient.



Once you’ve added your ingredients, click the “Cook” button to make your recipe food.



It’s that easy! There’s lots of recipes to make, and even more recipes you can unlock! If you enjoy cooking and crafting, then you’ll love Webkinz Next!


What are some of YOUR favorite secret recipe foods? Let us know in the comments below!




Follow us
Follow Webkinz on social media:




12 Responses to Jest the Best Bagel: Secret Sandwich Recipe Revealed!

  1. BH1464 says:

    By looking at the Jest the best Bagel I will keep imagining that it’s a bagel with cream cheese, strawberries, mango and kiwi fruit. That sounds as amazing as the Jest the best Bagel looks. lol

    • memmily says:

      Really? That looks like a smile made of a green pepper string, eyes of tomato, sour cream base, different colored taco chips and more green pepper strings with cheese balls on the ends for the joker hat, taco meat for the nose, so it works for me. But that version you made sounds like a real treat!

  2. BH1464 says:

    Wow! I would never have figured this one out. How can the Jest the best Bagel have strawberry slices for the eyes from a bagel, a pickle and a taco? Thanks for revealing this recipe because, as I said, I would never have figured it out. I thought I had two of the ingredients with a bagel and strawberries, but just needed to figure out the third. I was way off.

  3. wk2nd says:

    Question: Can you play webkinz NEXT on a chromebook?

  4. HorseInTheDessert says:

    Ew, tacos.

Leave a Reply