Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie: Secret Recipe Revealed!


Only a few weeks ago, we released a new Webkinz Secret Weekend for Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie—and it has already been solved!


Congratulations to monkeecj who was the first player to solve the recipe and receive the Secret Chef Trophy!





Now we can share the secret with everyone so they too can create this yummy new cookie to feed to their pets!


Here’s what you’ll need:


  • Fudge
  • Pink Lemonade
  • Waffles


Mix these ingredients together on a stove and you’ll create this sweet snack!





Want to know some more Secret Recipes? Check out our Secret Recipe archive here!


82 Responses to Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie: Secret Recipe Revealed!

  1. livandsky315 says:

    Are there any recipes that aren’t solved? I love experimenting!

  2. ninjario900 says:

    ganz please answer this question in the updates can u help me find the bake food to make the items please

    • Sally Webkinz says:

      The Bake Sale goods aren’t available yet. The Bake Sale will be happening from June 1 – June 10. More details will be posted later.

  3. blindfold11201 says:

    I love lemon cookies. Infact, I love most anything made with lemons! This sounds like a great combination, I’m looking forward to feeding them to my pets. Thanks mokneecj and Bon/Apetit.

  4. Immuyuk says:

    Oooh, I was hoping this was a real recipe that I could make at home. They look so yummy! Hello to all my WK BFFs from Essie**** You guys rock!

  5. maggiegreenbeen says:


Leave a Reply