Only a few weeks ago, we released a new Webkinz Secret Weekend for Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie—and it has already been solved!
Congratulations to monkeecj who was the first player to solve the recipe and receive the Secret Chef Trophy!
Now we can share the secret with everyone so they too can create this yummy new cookie to feed to their pets!
Here’s what you’ll need:
- Fudge
- Pink Lemonade
- Waffles
Mix these ingredients together on a stove and you’ll create this sweet snack!
Want to know some more Secret Recipes? Check out our Secret Recipe archive here!
Congratulations! :-)
Pink lemonade was one of the ingredients I tried, but fudge??? Yikes. I would have never guessed fudge in a lemon cookie recipe :,D I mean, I guess I tried pickles and toffee, so I can’t really say much about that xD But I thought there would have been at least lemon meringue. Anyways, congratz, monkey!! And thanks, Ganz, for the new cookie recipe!
ikr??? Yeah… i guessed Lemon Meringue pie, pink lemonade and bread! XD what does fudge have to do with Lemon cookies???? :/ Well ganz sure made it hard to guess! How did monkeecj ever guess that? I mean… WHOA! XP
I put cookies in every recipe I tried! Clearly, that didn’t work! XD
lol :)
Wow! I wasn’t even CLOSE!
Thanks monkeecj, for solving this recipe! Now we can all share this tasty treat with our pets!! Congrats on the solving!
Heheh….I COMPLETELY forgot about this recipe. Really, like, the day when they had this, I thought, “yeah, I’ll try this” and then….I forgot. Forever. That is, until today. Oh well, I NEVER would’ve guessed waffles and fudge. 1_1 anyways, congratulations for solving the recipe, monkeecj!! (I don’t know how you did it!) and enjoy your trophy! Or use the spoon in it to eat it. ;) yumm…
Ikr! I tried maybe 4 combos and then I completely forgot about it. i couldn’t get passed the idea of including cookies in the recipe! XD
I got so close to figuring it out!! I put pancakes pink lemonade and lemon meringue pie first then waffles pink lemonade and lemon meringue pie!!! Who New there was going to be fuge in the recipe!
Oops I spelled knew wrong sorry!
Wow, that seemed like a pretty hard one! Nice job, monkeecj, and congrats! =] I’ll be mixing up some cookies at my Webkinz house.
I mean, thats tricky! I tried pretty hard at this (er… not really) XD And really, what does FUDGE have to do with lemon cookies? XD
I’ll be baking alot of these for my pets! Lemon cookies are awesome. My mom buys these REALLY good star-shaped lemon cookies at the store and they are SO good. ;P
Ooh, those cookies sound good, fennec!! And yeah, I’m with you on that one. Fudge?? This isn’t a chocolate cookie were talking about here!! recipes are weird…yet delicous! (Or, at least delicous looking) =]
XD yeah ilovemoonie! I mean, fudge? in a lemon cookie? sounds good, but… XD
Hehe, yep! Oh, and ChristianCowgirl, lemon meringue pie, pink lemonade, and bread is a great guess!! I don’t know what I would have done, (if I had remembered about it,) but I can guarentee I wouldn’t have put fudge and waffles in there!! =\
AWWW thanks ilovemoonie! yah… if i forgot… and i remembered i would not put fudge!!!!!!!
Yeah… i guessed Lemon Meringue pie, pink lemonade and bread! XD what does fudge have to do with Lemon cookies???? :/ Well ganz sure made it hard to guess! How did monkeecj ever guess that? I mean… WHOA! XP
Fudge? What is chocolate doing in a lemon cookie? XD I kept on trying cookies!
Haha, yeah. =P They also used Pink Lemonade, which (there’s a normal lemonade, right?) I think was tricky. Plus.. waffles? Lol, oh well. I don’t know how you figured that one out, monkeecj!
Yeah… Fudge sure is an odd ingredient for lemon cookies… Same with waffles…. Now the pink lemonade didn’t come as a surprise to me. I knew that something containing lemon had to be in the recipe, but since regular lemons aren’t sold at the w shop, it would have to be either lemon meringue pie or pink lemonade. Oh, and emi, no, they don’t sell normal lemonade. I wish they did. After all, the more lemonade, the better! The w shop should consider selling normal and raspberry lemonade… Pink lemonade is amazing, but we could seriously use more varieties of lemonade… Well.. Er.. In my opinion (as you can see, I love lemonade!) heheh….. Well, uh, anyhow, congrats monkeecj for figuring out the recipe!
XD yes Taffy! more and MORE lemonade!
Yes! More lemonade! XD heheh… As you can tell, I’m a lemonade fanatic! And more lemonade at the w shop would be me so happy! :D Alomg with more awesome cookies. And cake. And pie. And ice cream! Okay, I’m just listing off my favorites here, heheh……
*I meant to say “along”, not “alomg” in my comment above. Sorry! Heheh…. Typo….
Lemonade!!! There should be a lemonade shop at the Clubhouse with a different variety of lemonade each day. Also, monkeej must have tried every combo possible to to get it!
Yes!! A lemonade shop at the clubhouse would be my dream!!! :,D And yeah, monkeecj must’ve tried countless combinations to get that recipe right! I never would’ve guessed that fudge and waffles were in it!
hehe yeah, emi! I mean… waffles? and if you put pink lemonade… the cookies would be pink-ish… right? XD
And yeah, monkeecj really stepped outside the box to find that one out! :P
XD yeah emi! I mean, fudge? in LEMON? XD lol
I agree with you! Fudge? and WAFFLES? XD I really didn’t try, but this looked super hard. Congrats monkeecj! Now I just need to make a device thats sucks these cookies out of the computer so I can eat them! XD -ilovemlp22
Lol, when you make that device ilovemlp22, could I please have one too?? Maybe you’ll have to share it on WKN like Ganz did with the cookies. Hopefully it won’t need waffles and fudge to make! ;)
This just blew my mind. Fudge? PINK Lemonade? Waffles? You’ve gotta be one super chef (on Webkinz) to be able to crack this recipe…and I guess that’s exactly what monkeecj is! I kept putting in Lemon Meringue Pie, lol! XD
Well, at least it’s solved! Can’t wait to bake up a batch for my Webkinz…and possibly even myself, lol!
Sweet! But wow, was I off! I thought the recipe would require cookies and lemon meringue pie. But it needed fudge and waffles, which are two ingredients I’d never guess we’re right. The lemonade, though, wasn’t much of a surprise. I thought the recipe would need it. Well, anywho, even though I kinda wish that I was the first one the figure out (who doesn’t want to win that trophy?), I want to congratulate monkeecj for figuring out the recipe and winning the trophy!!! :)
*I meant to say “the first one to figure it out”, not “the first one the figure out”. Sorry!!! Typos :/
XD me too! I was like, so off. I kept putting lemon meringue pie too lol! =)
Heheh, same here! I wasn’t even close! I kept using lemon meringue pie, cookies, pink lemonade, ice cream (I looked at the original recipe and it called for vanilla, but the only thing close to vanilla is that ice cream cone. I should’ve known that Webkinz recipes are almost never like the actual recipe in real life) and eggs (cookies are made with eggs, right??) and uh, well, I combined all of the above in different combinations and heheh… I just got gunk… I never would’ve guessed fudge and waffles were a part of the recipe!!!
haha, yeah! I mean, at first, i was so light-hearted! Baked my first er… um… gunk. Then my second. Then my third. Then my FOURTH. and well… i was like… WHAT? XD (I think i used grapefruit ONCE)
Heheh, same here! I expected to gunk the first few tries, but after my fourth or fifth, I started getting a little annoyed. And on my sixth or so, I just called it quits and hoped that somebody would eventually find out the recipe, heheh…. Also, to be honest, I don’t blame you for trying to put grapefruit in it! Webkinz recipes are always have at least one odd item (or two in this case) in it. Fudge? Waffles? I don’t really know what those two things have to do with a lemon cookie, heheh. But, I must say, I’m so glad the recipe is solved! Now I can make tons of lemon cookies for my pets XD
I never would have tried waffles or fudge! Fudge??? I still can’t believe it!
Going to make some Lemon Cookies now… BTW, having Lemon frizzy CANDY now!
Same here, doingmydailies! I never would’ve guessed! And that sounds good, SignatureIsland! Oh, how I wish I had some lemon cookies by me right now….
I thought it needed pink lemonade, cookies and eggs! Boy was I wrong! Well, I did get pink lemonade right! XD
Heheh, it’s okay, doingmydailies! I’m sure I tried the combination a few times, too. But hey, at least we both got one ingredient right! I had a feeling that pink lemonade would’ve been an ingredient… But waffles and fudge?! I never would’ve guessed!
Wow!!!! monkeecj, CONGRATS! I mean, i tried so hard at this… (well, not really) lol.