Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie: Secret Recipe Revealed!

 

Only a few weeks ago, we released a new Webkinz Secret Weekend for Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie—and it has already been solved!

 

Congratulations to monkeecj who was the first player to solve the recipe and receive the Secret Chef Trophy!

 

 

 

 

Now we can share the secret with everyone so they too can create this yummy new cookie to feed to their pets!

 

Here’s what you’ll need:

 

  • Fudge
  • Pink Lemonade
  • Waffles

 

Mix these ingredients together on a stove and you’ll create this sweet snack!

 

 

 

 

Want to know some more Secret Recipes? Check out our Secret Recipe archive here!

 

82 Responses to Polly’s Lovely Lemon Cookie: Secret Recipe Revealed!

  1. beerfeet says:

    Sally Webkinz – I made these cookies this morning as part of the Bon Appetite challenge but it did not give me credit for making a snack for my pet. I had to make a strawberry smoothie to get credit. Maybe this recipe is not in the system yet?

  2. FoxesRule612 says:

    I made these cookies yesterday! Man, I just wanna grab those right out of the screen! They look delicious!! =^^=

  3. lilypugrulestoo says:

    Congrats it is not an easy challenge…I was close I actually had the waffles and pink lemonade but I never thought to put anything chocolate in them

  4. MACS1 says:

    Does it matter which stove is used?

  5. HobbitJedi says:

    Wow, I thought the ingredients would be lemon pie, marshmallows and bananas, but I was way off!

    • wintergreene says:

      HobbitJedi, that combination makes a lot of sense and sounds much more appealing (he he) than the actual recipe! Webkinz should use yours for a banana cream pie recipe.

  6. NMKID4527 says:

    I can’t wait to make this! Congrats for being the first, monkeecj!!! You definitely earned that trophy! ;)

  7. 7debbie7 says:

    Congratulations monkeecj! Your new trophy is awesome!

  8. wintergreene says:

    CONGRATULATIONS Monkeecj! Most Excellent! I tried asparagus! How’d you get fudge? Weird, huh? Lemon cookies, YUM Lemon cookies with fudge? Not so much, Ganz!

  9. kitkat42 says:

    Wow, monkeecj, that’s eleven recipes you’ve solved!! Nice job! What’s your secret? haha jk ;)

  10. MisakiKt says:

    NEED TO EAT THAT!!!!!!! IT LOOKS SO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Leave a Reply